Halo Collar vs Spot On Fence Collar

We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive a commission. Learn more.

Dog with smart dog collar — Credit: Spot On Fence

You have decided to utilize a GPS Smart dog collar. Now, you are trying to choose the best GPS dog collar to keep your pup safe. Two notable options in the market are the Halo Collar and SpotOn Collar. This article will compare and contrast these two smart dog collars to help you decide on your beloved pet.

According to a recent study by Fact.MR that Pet Collar sales are likely to reach US$ 2 Billion as of the end of the year 2031.

Halo Callar

Introducing Halo Collar 3: Halo 3 always keeps your dog safe, anywhere in the world, with virtual fences, advanced real-time GPS tracking and activity monitoring — all managed through the user-friendly Halo app.

View on Halo Collar

Spot on fence GPS collar — Credit: Spot On

Spot On Collar

SpotOn GPS Fence is the most accurate, reliable, and easy to use. We've swapped buried wires with our patented True Location™ technology to bring you the most reliable GPS dog fence. Create fences in minutes, anytime and anywhere, so your dog can run free without running into trouble.

View on Spot On

Price: Halo Collar vs. SpotOn Collar

In terms of pricing, Halo ($699) is approximately half the cost of SpotOn ($1295). However, the variation in cost corresponds to discrepancies in quality and precision. SpotOn surpasses Halo in terms of performance and features by a substantial margin.

Halo necessitates a subscription plan to access data storage for fencing, GPS location services, activity tracking, and Cesar Millan's training. On the other hand, SpotOn's fences can be used without a subscription, but you'll need one for escape alerts and GPS tracking. While Halo's basic plan is quite basic, but we suggest opting for at least the Silver plan at $9.99 to fully leverage the collar's functionalities.

Both products offer financing options, subject to a credit check and approval. The terms for Halo are relatively shorter, but SpotOn offers a lower monthly cost due to its extended repayment period.

If we consider the price winner based on the lowest initial cost, Halo takes the lead in this category. However, it's important to note that Halo also entails a monthly fee, which means that SpotOn emerges as the cost-effective option in the long run.

In a closely contested match, Halo comes out on top in terms of affordability due to its lower initial price compared to SpotOn.

Features and Training Comparison

Alert options: Both systems offer various correction levels, including tone, vibration, and static modes. However, SpotOn provides a broader selection of 30 options, while Halo offers 15.

It's worth noting that SpotOn's beep alert is significantly louder than Halo's, which is relatively subtle but still audible to dogs while they're wearing the collar.

Vibrations are comparable on both systems and allow for intensity adjustments. In the case of Halo, the third shock level is quite intense but not painful.

Custom fences: Both Halo and SpotOn allow you to save up to 20 of them simultaneously. However, when it comes to creating non-safe or "keep out" zones, Halo requires the use of a physical Bluetooth "beacon" device that comes with the system (additional beacons can be purchased). In contrast, SpotOn allows you to establish no-go or home zones directly within the app, providing more flexibility.

Apps: Both systems offer apps for fence management and feedback for your dog. They include video training to assist with collar setup and acclimating your dog to the fencing system. Both also allow you to manage multiple pets and toggle fence settings. Tracking is included in Halo's plans but is an add-on for SpotOn.

Halo benefits from the expertise of dog trainers, including Cesar Millan, and its app offers numerous tutorials, step-by-step videos, tips, and tricks for dog training. While SpotOn provides several instructional videos on how to make your dog respond to alerts, its app primarily focuses on containment and tracking, not training. Therefore, Halo is a better choice for ongoing behavior modification.

Both systems are highly portable and suitable for various terrains. SpotOn stands out with its Forest Mode, designed for yards with dense tree cover, enhancing GPS sensitivity when activated.

One noticeable difference is the lag time, with Halo exhibiting a longer delay compared to the almost immediate responsiveness of SpotOn. Although Halo offers more training tools, SpotOn holds a slight advantage in this category.

Performance Winner: SpotOn

Coverage

Now, let's delve into the coverage capabilities of each collar and the technology they employ.

Coverage Area: SpotOn's optimal performance is recommended for properties spanning at least 1/2 acre, while Halo can be effectively used in smaller yards, as small as 0.2 acres. It's worth noting that SpotOn requires some spacing between barriers, so the fence lines cannot be placed too close together. Based on these specifications, it's evident that SpotOn is tailored for larger properties.

Precision: Both companies rely on multiple constellation satellites that transmit positioning and timing data to the collars' built-in antennas. The Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS), encompassing GPS, is not entirely foolproof, and both companies have received some criticism regarding the consistency of their performance. However, SpotOn stands out by having its dedicated satellite and twice the number, rendering it more precise and dependable.

SpotOn garners fewer complaints concerning the accuracy of fencing boundaries and location tracking compared to Halo. One key differentiator contributing to this variance is the positioning of each collar's antenna: SpotOn's is directly on top of the collar, while Halo's is located on the side.

Boundary Configuration: SpotOn allows you to establish up to 1,500 fence posts, which can overlap each other. In contrast, Halo permits the setup of only 20 fence posts, and overlapping them is not an option.

Creating boundaries with Halo involves manually placing a fence post marker, akin to physical fence posts. On the other hand, SpotOn automatically generates these boundaries as you walk, and you can make manual adjustments as needed.

We found it notably easier to set up fence boundaries with SpotOn by merely walking the perimeter of the desired containment area. Halo, on the other hand, proved less user-friendly and less precise, making the setup process somewhat frustrating. Posts could be dropped, but their placement was not always accurate, necessitating adjustments. Additionally, Halo predominantly employs linear fence lines, whereas SpotOn offers greater flexibility in contouring to the shape of your space.

SpotOn unquestionably excels in terms of simplifying the creation of fence zones. It allows for a larger number of zones and is more accurate than Halo.

Performance Winner: SpotOn

Overall Winner

The ultimate decision between these two options hinges on your specific requirements. SpotOn excels in terms of potentially more precise GPS tracking and fencing boundaries, as well as enhanced customizability in terms of fencing and correction levels. For those seeking a wireless fence solution, SpotOn is the more favorable choice. However, if you're working within a budget and have a smaller yard, Halo might be a suitable alternative.

When making a comprehensive comparison of collar features and selecting a clear winner, SpotOn emerges as our top choice. While it may represent an initial investment, the benefits of having a virtual fence that adapts to your needs make it a valuable choice.

Conclusive Winner: SpotOn

FAQs

Return policy?

Halo collar return policy

**If you are not completely satisfied with your purchase for any reason (excluding animal-induced or customer-induced damage) during your first 60 days after you receive your originally purchased collar, you may return it to us for a refund of your purchase price (less $25 shipping, handling and taxes, where applicable) according to their terms and conditions.

Spot on collar return policy

RETURN REQUEST must be submitted within 90 days from date of shipment and received within 10 days after the return is requested. When returning, please ensure the order number is clearly written on the outside of the box.

Are these intelligent dog collars compatible with all canine breeds and sizes?

The Halo Collar and SpotOn Collar are crafted to cater to a wide range of dog breeds and sizes. Nonetheless, it's advisable to verify the collar's specifications to guarantee a comfortable fit for your dog.

Is a monthly subscription required for these collars?

Indeed, both collars necessitate a monthly subscription to unlock their full array of features and services. Typically, these subscription fees encompass GPS tracking, app accessibility, and customer support.

Are these collars waterproof?

Absolutely, both collars are designed to be either water-resistant or waterproof, granting your dog the freedom to partake in outdoor activities even in damp conditions. It's prudent to review the specific waterproof rating to ascertain it suits your dog's requirements.

Can I track multiple dogs with these collars?

Certainly, both the Halo Collar and SpotOn Collar permit you to monitor multiple dogs via their respective apps. You can conveniently add each dog's profile and manage them collectively in one place.

Can I use these collars for training purposes?

Absolutely! Both the Halo Collar and SpotOn Collar offer training functionalities, including remote cues, vibrations, and behavior assistance. Nevertheless, I'd like to ask professional trainers for precise training techniques and counsel to help.

What are the key features of GPS dog collars like SpotOn and Halo?

GPS dog collars, like SpotOn and Halo, offer a bunch of cool stuff! Think real-time tracking, tracking history, setting up virtual boundaries, keeping tabs on your pet's activity, and sometimes even helping out with training.

What distinguishes SpotOn GPS Dog Fence technology?

SpotOn fence is all about creating this invisible but super-effective fence! You can define where your furry buddy should stay using GPS—no physical fences needed!

How does the Halo collar differ from SpotOn in terms of features?

Ah, Halo and SpotOn—both awesome but with their own vibes! Halo might focus more on training features, while SpotOn dog collar rocks at setting up those GPS boundaries for safety.

What should I consider in a Halo vs. SpotOn GPS comparison for my dog?

As a dog owner It’s all about what your dog needs! Halo dog collar for training buffs, SpotOn virtual fence for boundary lovers. Pick the one that suits your furry friend’s style and keeps them safe and happy!